Interior shot of a driver and passenger operating a vehicle.

New Proposal Could Let Drivers Share Personal Data to Lower Insurance Costs

Editor’s note: AB 311 did not advance during the 2026 legislative session. We’ve updated this article to reflect the bill’s status and what California drivers could see in the future.

California drivers could still face a new question when shopping for auto insurance in the future: how much of their driving data they’d be willing to share in exchange for potential savings.

With auto insurance costs putting pressure on household budgets, a proposed California bill, Assembly Bill 311 (AB 311), explored a new approach to how insurers evaluate driving behavior and determine premiums. The proposal would have allowed drivers to voluntarily share data—including speed, braking, location, and swerving—with insurance companies when calculating rates.

Supporters believed the change could reward safer driving habits and encourage better decisions behind the wheel. However, consumer advocates and regulators raised questions about data privacy, pricing transparency, and whether the program would consistently deliver savings.

Although AB 311 did not advance this session, the proposal raises an important question for California drivers: Could sharing your driving data help lower your insurance costs, or are there other ways to save without sacrificing your privacy?

What Is AB 311, and How Could It Change Auto Insurance?

California has traditionally restricted how insurance companies use driving information when setting auto insurance premiums. Under the state’s existing framework, insurers must prioritize factors such as driving safety records, miles driven, and driving experience.

AB 311 would have allowed participating drivers to opt in to telematics-based programs, giving insurers another source of information to evaluate driving behavior alongside traditional records. (Telematics are data transmissions over long distances.)

Telematics technology can collect driving information through several methods, including:

  • Smartphone apps: Applications that record driving activity while a driver is on the road.
  • Vehicle technology: Connected systems built into a vehicle that transmit driving data.
  • Other connected devices: Technologies that monitor and report specific driving behaviors.

Depending on the program, the information collected may include speed, hard braking, rapid acceleration, sharp turns, trip routes, and driving frequency.

If similar legislation is introduced and enacted in the future, California drivers could have another option when seeking insurance savings. Rather than relying exclusively on conventional rating factors, participating drivers could potentially demonstrate safer driving habits through the data collected by a telematics program. However, participation would be voluntary under the AB 311 proposal, and the availability and amount of any discount would depend on the insurer and the program’s terms.

Could Sharing Your Driving Data Actually Lower Your Premium?

The possibility of earning a discount for safer driving is one of the main reasons telematics programs have attracted attention. Drivers who consistently avoid speeding, sudden braking, and aggressive turns may be interested in programs that reward those behaviors. For some motorists, demonstrating responsible driving could offer another avenue to potentially reduce their insurance expenses.

Research suggests the results can vary. A 2024 Consumer Reports survey found median annual savings of approximately $120 among the telematics users surveyed. However, the survey also found that some drivers experienced increases in their insurance costs.

Maryland Insurance Administration data cited in reporting on AB 311 showed similarly mixed results among drivers enrolled in telematics programs in 2023:

  • 31% saw their rates decrease.
  • 24% experienced an increase.
  • 45% saw no change in their premiums.

These findings illustrate why drivers should carefully review the terms of any telematics program before enrolling. A program that advertises potential savings does not guarantee that every participant will receive a discount. It’s also important to recognize that results from other states may not predict what California drivers would experience if similar legislation is introduced and enacted.

What Should You Consider Before Enrolling?

Before agreeing to share your driving information, ask the insurer:

  • What specific data will be collected?
  • How will driving behavior affect my premium?
  • Could my rate increase if the data indicates riskier driving?
  • Who can access my information, and how long will it be retained?
  • Can the data be shared with third-party providers or used for other purposes?
  • Can I leave the program, and what happens to my data if I do?

Understanding these details can help you determine whether the potential benefit is worth the trade-offs.

Privacy, Transparency, and Fairness Remain Key Concerns

While telematics may offer another way to evaluate driving behavior, it also introduces questions about how personal information is collected and used. Location data, for example, can reveal more than driving habits. It may also expose patterns about where someone lives, works, and travels. Some drivers may be uncomfortable sharing that level of information, even if a discount is available.

Critics have also questioned whether the algorithms used to evaluate driving behavior could produce unfair results. A driver who regularly travels on congested roads, navigates challenging routes, or drives during late-night hours may have different driving patterns from someone with a shorter, more predictable commute. Depending on how a program evaluates those patterns, a driver’s circumstances could affect their score in ways that may not fully reflect their overall safety.

California’s insurance regulators have raised concerns about oversight, the use of third-party data providers, and whether telematics-based pricing would fit within the state’s existing insurance laws.

Consumer advocates have also questioned whether savings would be sufficiently consistent and whether drivers could feel pressured to surrender privacy to afford an insurance product they are legally required to carry. 

These concerns do not mean every telematics program will produce unfair results. They do highlight the importance of understanding how a program works, what protections apply, and whether the potential savings justify the information being shared.

You Don’t Have to Wait for Telematics to Review Your Insurance Costs

Regardless of whether similar legislation is introduced in the future, California drivers can take steps today to understand their existing auto insurance coverage and explore potential savings.

One option is to review your current policy with the help of DRO’s network of insurance carriers and agents. Instead of assuming that a telematics program is necessary to lower your premium, a policy review can help identify opportunities based on your existing coverage, driving profile, and available insurance options.

Depending on your circumstances and the carriers available, a review may help you explore:

  • Potentially more competitive rates: Compare available insurance options to see whether another carrier may offer a better fit for your needs.
  • Available discounts: Determine whether you qualify for discounts based on factors such as driving history, mileage, vehicle features, or policy eligibility.
  • Coverage adjustments: Review deductibles, limits, and optional coverage to understand whether your current policy aligns with your needs and budget.
  • Policy details worth revisiting: Identify coverage questions, potential gaps, or policy features you may want to discuss with a licensed insurance professional.
  • Telematics options, if available: If a participating carrier offers a program that fits your circumstances, review its terms and potential benefits before deciding whether to enroll.

The goal is to find the right balance between affordability and protection. DRO can help California drivers review their existing auto insurance coverage, compare available options through our network of insurance carriers and agents, and identify potential savings based on their individual circumstances. Whether you’re concerned about rising premiums or simply want to know if your current policy is still competitive, you don’t have to wait for new legislation to take a closer look.

Have questions about your auto insurance costs? Contact DRO to review your coverage and explore your options.

Update: What Happened to AB 311?

AB 311 did not pass during the 2026 California legislative session. The bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee on August 13, 2026, ending its chances of advancing this session. California lawmakers could introduce similar legislation during the 2027–28 legislative session under a new bill number. However, no such legislation has been announced at this time. For now, AB 311 remains a proposal that did not become law. California drivers should not assume that telematics-based insurance pricing will become available under this proposal, but the broader conversation about driving data, insurance costs, and consumer privacy could continue in future legislative sessions.